How Do We Know What They
Know?
Using Non-traditional
Evaluation
Methods
It’s not uncommon for
moms examining
Epi Kardia curriculum
for possible purchase to
ask “How will I know what
my child has learned if
there aren’t any tests?”
Unit studies lend to this
thinking and we completely
understand why this is a
concern. We had the same
concerns for our children
as we developed Epi Kardia
curriculum.
So, how do we know
what they know? For
Epi Kardia and
other parents using
unit studies,
non-traditional
evaluation methods
provide the answers.
In reality, these
methods should be
used to some extent
no matter what
subject or what
curriculum we’re
using. Why? Well,
test banks offered
with textbook
programs often fail
to truly evaluate
what children are
actually learning.
They may evaluate if
a child knows the
material on the test,
but they can’t even
guarantee that
result. Due to
various learning
styles, some children
will never succeed
with traditional
testing methods. By
using a wide variety
of evaluation
methods, we can more
thoroughly determine
if our children are
learning what we deem
to be important.
One excellent benefit
of non-traditional
evaluation is that
these methods may be
adapted for students
from Kindergarten to
high school, allowing
us, as parents, to
select methods that
promote our students’
gifts and provide
positive, challenging
learning experiences
at the same time.
Just as a unit study
moves students to
think out of the box,
parents have to do
the same in order to
evaluate such
achievement.
When
evaluating our
children, we want to
determine whether we
are seeking factual
or processing
responses. Factual
responses, such as
when we ask our child
a question like “What
are some achievements
of the Ancient
Egyptians?”
demonstrate a child’s
knowledge of the
important points.
Processing responses,
as with a question
like “What do you
think it was like for
children during the
Middle Ages?” require
our children to think
and apply what
they’ve learned, then
respond
appropriately. Strong
communication is a
key to
non-traditional
assessment as we
always want to
clearly articulate to
our children what is
expected of
them.
Tools such as rubrics
and checklists
combined with other
evaluation methods
not only provide
assessment for us as
parents and teachers,
but they also allow
our children to know
ahead of time what we
expect of them. This
not only provides a
greater opportunity
for success, but also
promotes confidence
as our children more
readily understand
our goals for them.
Some non-traditional
assessment ideas to
consider as you plan
for your children
include:
-
Narration/oral
presentations
-
What
did you
learn?
(factual)
-
Book
reports
-
What
do you
think?
(processing)
-
Oral
quizzes
(factual
and
processing)
-
Written
presentations and
materials
-
Essays
-
Journalistic
reports
-
Advertising
-
Reports
-
Reviews
-
Poetry
-
Song
lyrics
-
Children’s
materials
-
Visual and Graphic
organizers
-
Lap books, mini
books
-
Maps,
overlays
-
Outlines,
thinking
maps
-
Scrapbooking
-
Tri-fold board
presentations
(similar to
science fair,
but with
different
subject
matter)
-
Artistic
expression
-
Drawing,
painting,
sculpture
-
Architecture,
building,
design
-
Models
-
Dramatic
expression
-
Theatrical
presentation
-
Playwriting
-
Evaluative
assignments and
projects
-
Creating
puzzles,
comprehension
questions,
activity
ideas
-
Co-op style
activities
(working on a
small part of a
larger
project)
The
Epi Kardia Teacher’s
Manual
salso provide
additional discussion and
ideas related to
non-traditional assessment.
The Epi Kardia
Tools CD, available as
part of an
Epi Kardia Complete
Program, provides
templates for checklists
and rubrics, as well as
other organizational charts
for parents and students
alike. If you have any
questions about
non-traditional evaluation
methods and how to use
them, feel free to contact
us or visit our
blog as we respond to
other parents’
questions.
Many
Blessings,
Beth
New High
School Courses
Available on our
Website!
Three
new high school courses are
now available for sale on
our
website:
Essay Styles for High
School - We
recommend this foundational
high school essay course as
a first course in high
school writing. Rounded out
with the addition of
literature and vocabulary
study, this course is
superb preparation for high
school writing and
beyond.
Designed with step by step,
detailed instructions for
both the student and the
teacher,
even parents who do not
view themselves as strong
writers can teach this
course because the
evaluation section
describes exactly what you
need to look for in your
student’s writing and
explains how to determine a
fair grade, as
well.
A Study in American
Writers -
Treat
yourself and your student
to some of the finest
writing to originate in
America. Combining poetry,
a play, short stories and
novels, this one full
year/credit American
literature course will
provide your student with a
wide variety of reading and
writing experiences
including literary
components, vocabulary,
essay writing and creative
projects. This curriculum
also includes options for
an honors credit. (We
recommend
Essay Styles as a
prerequisite for this
course, and they can also
be taught
concurrently.)
The Steps to Writing a
Research Paper -
Whether covering the
effects of World War II or
analyzing the sounds
produced by an electric
guitar, we recommend
that at least two research
papers be written by every
high school student.
From
choosing an appropriate
topic to note taking and
research to understanding
MLA and APA formatting,
this course provides
meaningful training that
will benefit your student
not only in high school,
but throughout college.
Examples and non-examples
of how to create an
excellent research paper
allow students to avoid
common pitfalls. The
evaluation section gives
parents and teachers the
tools and information
necessary for accurately
grading each of the steps
and the final
paper.